In the House of Lords. George Haldane of Gleneagles, Esquire, Appellant. The Officers of State in Scotland, on behalf of his Majesty, the Governor and Company of Undertakers for raising Thames Water in York Buildings, the Hon. John Elphinston, Assignee of George Keith, late Earl Marischal of Scotland deceased, and James Ferguson of Pitfour, Esquire. Respondents. The case of the Respondent, the Honourable John Elphinston.